Who's the most skillful of CoD players: Console or PC?

[MoistPuss]

lol, that dudes played the pit way too much. That was slick to me. I got 3 stars on it though. like 1 sec faster.

[Jugz]

I'm sure it's already been addressed, but each will be better in their own device. PC players have better aim because they use a mouse. Guess what? When you play on a console, you don't use a mouse.
The top players of each system eventually reach a peak level where no, they really can't get any better. That is the bar you set as a human being. Just because you play on a different system doesn't mean that you, as a human, are superior at gaming on all systems. If I'm an expert at washing dishes, my neighbor isn't going to be better at washing dishes just because he's an expert at washing dogs.

I would expect that if the best PC players went up against the best console players ON A CONSOLE, they would get beaten. Opposite effect will happen if you play them on a PC.

[Chris Hanson]

Penguinman NI. Check his combat record on black ops.

Legend on PC as well.

He plays 360

[Tubby_Custard]

For a FAMAS user...

but yeah he is pretty good. Didn't know he played PC.

[Vnzuelan Dude]

3. They are equal in skill.

If they are equal in skill you might as well throw out the whole argument out the window.
Because that means that not one is better than the other. They'll make the same mistakes, have the same reaction, and go down the same road. Regardless on what station they are on.

This is my analogy for the discussion: You have two strippers.
They work in the same club, for the same amount of time, and have enough experience to do a splits.

However, PC is a double-jointed stripper. Which means she can be more flexible than Console.
At some point Console is going to reach her limit and won't be able to stretch those legs any farther.
But PC can continue to improve. PC can train harder to get those legs as far back as you want them to.
Does that mean that all PC strippers will be that motivated to entertain you?
No. Because some strippers are only trying to put themselves through college. Or some other excuse for sucking.

[Jugz]

If they are equal in skill you might as well throw out the whole argument out the window.
Because that means that not one is better than the other. They'll make the same mistakes, have the same reaction, and go down the same road. Regardless on what station they are on.

This is my analogy for the discussion: You have two strippers.
They work in the same club, for the same amount of time, and have enough experience to do a splits.

However, PC is a double-jointed stripper. Which means she can be more flexible than Console.
At some point Console is going to reach her limit and won't be able to stretch those legs any farther.
But PC can continue to improve. PC can train harder to get those legs as far back as you want them to.
Does that mean that all PC strippers will be that motivated to entertain you?
No. Because some strippers are only trying to put themselves through college. Or some other excuse for sucking.

I don't think that's right. If the stripper can do double jointed splits, it's because she's taking a muscle relaxer to do it. If she competes with the non-muscle-relaxer-using stripper without using muscle relaxers, she is only going to be able to do splits of around the same distance as her competitor.

[TheMeInTeam]

The actual question is whether it is more skillful to play with mouse and keyboard or on a controller. Obviously mouse and keyboard are more effective and players using them will win, but that doesn't mean the person is actually a better player overall, just that he is currently wielding a superior tool.

Most of CoD is movement, especially with client side hit detection and lag comp factoring even the best human reaction times in the world are often trumped.

[flipper_gv]

btw

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9Hwj2F-ucg

[Boz]

This guy wiped 9secs off my time.

[skyamerico]

I consider myself a good FPS player.

I am good because I have a huge experience with my mouse+keyboard on FPS and other games:

FPS - Doom, Heretic, Duke Nukem, Quake 1-3, Counter Strike, MW1, MW2, Black Ops, MW3
MMOs - Ultima Online, World of Warcraft, Age of Conan, Rift, SWTOR.

All those games I have hundreds/thousands of gameplay hours. (I am prety sure that I have played World of Warcraft more days than most African children live).

Last month I went to my friends house and tryed to play MW3 on his PS3. lol.... I couldn't even run without moving my camera to the floor or the sky. I think I only manage to kill people with my claymore because I know the good spots.

Give me a mouse+keyboard and you will see a GOD playing. Give me a joystick and you will se the noobest person on Earth playing.